How to Prioritize when Everything is High Priority: the Data-Driven Approach
Post was originally published on April 2020 and has been updated in March 2023 for relevancy
At a company where data is core to business, to help make data-driven decisions, I recommend the following 5-step prioritization approach, which builds on the RICE prioritization method, to determine which initiative to move forward with.
Step 1: List all possible initiatives you're considering, from pie-in-the-sky to the short-term.
Step 2: Decide what the timeline to deliverable is, e.g. next quarter, next board meeting, etc.
Step 3: Score each item in the list on the following 4 attributes, each on a low/medium/high scale:
Impact: Expected business impact -- in profit/savings or towards mission
Note: If it solves an (internal/external) client pain point, how does that translate into business impact?
Confidence: Data availability
Effort: Timeline to deliverable, including feasibility in hitting the timeline specified in Step 2
This includes considering whether the solution is a product/service that already exists and that you can buy (e.g. the "build vs buy" consideration). Especially if the deliverable won't be core to main product/service the company's offering, consider the "buy" route.
Step 4: Sort according to those that score high on business impact, breaking ties with those products that are more interconnected.
Step 5: Discuss results of Step 4 based on the other attributes to determine the next initiative.
Step 6: Repeat all of the above towards the end of the timeline (specified in Step 2) to plan the next phase, e.g. potentially quarterly.
Keywords: Data products, prioritization, productivity
You may also like:
The 6 Decision-Making Frameworks That Help Startup Leaders Tackle Tough Calls, by First Round Review
How to prioritize features in your product backlog by Adam Bader
How to Prioritize When Everything Feels Important, by Jessica Greene
How to Prioritize your Work when your Manager Doesn't by Amy Jen Su
My Team Constantly Back-Burners My Priorities, by quickbase
3 Steps to Creating a Minimum Viable Launch by Ilana Brown
How Basecamp does this: Shape Up: Stop Running in Circles and Ship Work that Matters, by Ryan Singer